我想不通。
港片,往往要在一些国家播放时,就必须被抹杀它最初的原音--粤语。硬是要配和表情、情绪不搭,意思有出入的华语进去! 把整部戏弄得怪里怪气的!
说:粤语是一种方言,不适合提倡?但是他们允许自己本土的方言出现在影片中。
说:怕自己人民听不懂?拜托,可以放字幕好不好?! 要中文、英文还是马来文,随便你!
最好笑的是其他外语片(日本、韩国、法国等等)却可以用自己原本的语言在当地放映。这难道不是双重标准吗?
我看外语片的习惯是-即使听不懂、要费力地看字幕; 我还是会选择去听演员们用自己的语言说出来的话。这比较原汁原味。看和听起来都比较舒服。
在新加坡,所有上映的港片都是配上了华语。
我不能说配音员不专业,只是觉得这样会少了港片原有的味道。
而且,有一些俚语是很难用华语来直接翻译。
像港剧《溏心风暴》里,陳豪飾演的“得得地”,华语竟然翻译成:“还可以”。。。。。你看,是不是很怪?!
嗯,不知你们有没有同感?如果这些国家放宽胸怀,还给港片一个最初的声音;我想港片的票房会更好一些。
Wow! I can't believe that I will be the first one to leave comment oh. Bao, I strongly agree with you. I prefer to watch HK Drama in Cantonese language too wor! That will really make the whole drama has more 'feeling' to me. hehe...
ReplyDeleteTruly agree, the translation did not reflect the actual meaning of the phrase, using Cantonese is more lively.
ReplyDeleteThey block it previously was because too much of different dialects in the small country, in order to avoid the nature of dialects cause the different thinkings, then they want to standardize everything to one language, English or Chinese. But now, since it's too long ago, no one bother whether this policy still working or still effective, so, still doing something silly to change the language to all Hongkong/Taiwan Series lar, cos the rule and regulation still there. ;D
不管是那国的电影或演员, 我都喜欢听原音. 像香港演员拍中国片我都希望是他们自己说对白而不是配音, 即使华语不标准也没关系. 最重要他能演出精彩.
ReplyDeletewhat can i say? totally agree with you guys! that's why i don't like to see hong kong movies in the cinema anymore. i remember when i was in scotland, i was able to enjoy movies like Kong Fu hustle and 2046 in cantonese. something is very wrong with the system here...
ReplyDelete绝对支持港片应该以粤语放映!!!一些粤语中的精髓,中文翻译完全不到位,让影片本身也失色不少!!! 新加坡政府也是时候好好重新评估这个旧条例了。凭什么大半部片子都在讲福建话的国产片就可以原音放映?
ReplyDelete好像台湾也是一样。会将港片配上华语才上映。
ReplyDeleteBao, Happy birthday to your Blog~~
ReplyDelete"Tuesday, April 21, 2009 格蕾丝 开张大吉! "
hahahahaha
So fast a year past~~~ Keep up the good work and write more to your faithful readers! =)
ReplyDelete原来宝的是和萍同一天生日的?!呵呵,幸好在马来西亚没有这个问题,我也不喜欢看港片讲华语哩,有谁可以发动签名运动让有关单位省思?
ReplyDelete小燕子的主意不错.我们可以考虑一下.
ReplyDelete但只怕他们认为我们是激进分子,将我们赶出这个国家! 哈哈.
Peng & Vanessa, thank you. I would try my best to write more and more.. :D
ReplyDelete